I'm so happy to be finally able to make a post about the "making" of this cake:
About a month ago, I got the idea to make a hat-shaped cake for Sameer's birthday. Initially, I had no idea how to even go about doing it. So naturally, I searched "how to make a hat cake" on Google and watched every YouTube video tutorial out there on making hat-shaped cakes.
Another piece of interesting information is that I've also never baked a cake from scratch. So, on top of my hat cake research ... I also did a bunch of research on tips for baking a perfect cake. Thankfully, I came across Yolanda Gampp's amazing blog (
How to Cake It) - she had the perfect vanilla cake recipe for cake decorating and also a YouTube video on making a baseball cap cake. And so, I decided to go with her vanilla cake recipe for my cake.
Here is everything I used to make the cake:
- 1 and 1/2 cups of unsalted butter
- 3 cups of sugar
- 1 and 1/2 tsp of vanilla extract
- 6 eggs
- 1 and 1/2 cups of milk
- 3 and 3/4 cups of flour
- 1 tbsp and 1 tsp of baking powder
- 3/4 tsp
- 2 large mixing bowls
- 1 stainless steel bowl
- 1 hand mixer
- 1 sift
- Duncan Hines' vanilla buttercream
- Bristol board
- Wilton's Black and white fondant
- Wilton's fondant decorating tools
- 1 cake board
- 1 rolling pin (or wine bottle)
- 1 serrated knife
- 1 sharp paring knife
- 1 mini paintbrush
I had planned on taking pictures of every step ... but at one point, I got way too into it and completely forgot to take pictures. Here's a collection of pictures I did take:
I took the butter, eggs and milk (I poured the amount needed into a bowl) out of the fridge in advance so that they could be at room temperature. This allows the ingredients to blend together better.
Step 1: Sift the flour, salt and baking powder and whisk them together in one bowl.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhCJbZdzQkc8Xzh6KWP-_XJEIPBQW0tsMVDlRcFQoYWmzarcYnejE3jYDWzcg_zoejcEgRH4EBXOCmo66rcVVpBB7XeilAL1CtRtkFvEOy51XvJX6tiwjCf_P29xgDdDmVo-BwUSHTWGTc/s640/FullSizeRender+%25281%2529.jpg) |
I made sure to level off each measurement with the back edge of a knife to make sure the amounts were exact. |
Step 2: Cream the butter and sugar.
I put the butter and sugar together in another mixing bowl and used my hand mixer to blend them together. A good tip I learned for using the hand mixer was to place the mixer in the ingredients before turning it on ... as opposed to starting it and then going in from above. Yes, I learned this the hard way because the latter method caused A LOT of splattering. Once the butter and sugar is well-blended, the mixture should be completely smooth with no lumps or bumps.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgj2daLVHKQEVXPzd7m0GC75-pffwF54NlPN0Zo9cKi1CtEY7Zy7THYaU77zNxHnVr3jggVgwtalGFqaItHlqbDrIG5-Kp5KMlP7EdvjR3ia4CFzeyJ7qmMR2Fhh7XrD1XV-fm332_d_0o/s640/FullSizeRender+%25282%2529.jpg) |
My rubber spatula came in really handy when I needed to scrape the sides of the mixing bowl. |
Step 3: Add the eggs.
I cracked the eggs into one bowl and added them to the mixture two at a time (as suggested by Yolanda Gampp). I made sure the eggs were fully blended into the mixture before adding more.
Step 4: Add in the dry ingredients and milk to the mix.
I followed Yolanda's instructions for this step and it worked really well. She suggests adding the dry ingredients alternatively with the milk, starting with the dry ingredients - 4 parts of dry ingredients and 3 parts of milk.
Step 5: Dye the batter (if you want to).
I wanted to dye the batter a dark purple colour (for the Raptors!!!). I started by adding the red food colouring... then the blue food colouring.
Step 6: Line baking bowl with parchment paper and grease bowl.
I cut slits into a circular parchment liner to line the bottom of the stainless steel bowl and then greased the sides of the bowl with some butter.
Step 7: Pour in the good stuff.
... and after this, I started slacking on the picture-taking. I followed Yolanda's instructions - pre-heated the oven to 350 degrees, and then plopped the batter into the oven. Based on the amount of batter I made, the bake time should have been 1 hr and 20 min. BUT because the bowl I used to bake the batter in was so deep, it took closer to 2 hrs for the whole thing to bake. I checked on the cake periodically and stuck a knife down the centre to see if if it would come out clean. Once the knife came out clean, I took it out out of the oven and let it cool over night. I draped a clean dish towel over it to keep the cake from drying out.
Step 8: Remove the cake from the bowl.
I had a HELL OF A HARD TIME taking the cake out of the bowl. I ran a knife along the side of the cake and tried to shake it out while holding the bowl upside down, but no luck. It took me about 15 min to finally get the thing out. I had to eventually use my knife as a lever to pry it out. When the cake finally felt loose, I flipped it over to let us fall out on its own ... and
IT FELL OUT IN 3 SEPARATE PIECES. After having a panic attack and nearly crying over the cake disaster ... I improvised a bit and glued the pieces back together with my vanilla buttercream. Surprisingly, this actually worked out pretty well.
Step 9: Shape the cake.
I used one of my Blue Jays hats and traced the shape of the base of the hat and the brim onto a piece of bristol board. I then flipped the cake upside down and trimmed it with a serrated knife to the shape of the base of the hat. I also trimmed all around the cake until I got it to look more or less like the shape of a hat.
I set the template for the brim of the hat aside until I got the fondant ready.
Step 10: Frost the cake.
In the professional caking world, I believe this step is called "crumb coating" ... because it coats the outside of the cake and keeps the crumbs in. I put layer of vanilla buttercream evenly over the entire surface of the cake. Then I let it set in the fridge for about 30 - 40 min.
Step 11: Put cake on cake board.
Once the frosting on the outside of the cake was set (it's hard to the touch), I carefully removed the cake from the baking sheet and placed it onto my "cake board". You can buy actual cake boards that are specifically used for cake presentation. I used a canvas board that I got from Dollarama for $2. To get the cake to stay put, you can put more frosting on the bottom of the cake before placing it onto the board (and then let set for another 30 - 40 min). I didn't bother with this because I didn't have time. I placed the cake directly onto the board.
Step 12: Fondant time.
I got my fondant from Michael's. I bought 1.5 lbs of black and white Wilton's fondant. I wasn't sure how much I would actually need. I only needed the white for the lettering on the front, but I figured I would get extra to be safe.
I started off by kneading the fondant to get it softer for rolling. After that, I used my rolling pin to flatten out the fondant. At first, I rolled it in all directions. When it started getting thinner, I started rolling it out from the centre to make everything even. I think the general rule is to get it to 1/8th of an inch thick. Once I got it to the right thickness, I lifted it up on one side and rolled it halfway onto my rolling pin ... and then I VERY quickly flipped it onto the cake.
The one thing I've heard time and time again about fondant is that you have to work very quickly when you're covering the cake because the fondant stretches when you lift it and can rip easily.
When I was happy that my cake was covered evenly, I cut off the excess fondant (leaving about 1 inch around the cake) with a sharp paring knife. Then I pushed the fondant that was left gently towards the cake, in a tucking motion. I've heard that fondant tends to shrink up the sides once it starts to dry, so I wanted to avoid that. After that, I used my paring knife again to cut away the remaining fondant, keeping as close to the cake as possible. I used the template I had made out of bristol board for the brim of the hat and traced around it to cut the fondant into the same shape. I cut slightly bigger around the template, to avoid the same shrinking problem I mentioned earlier. Before connecting the brim to the rest of the hat, I rolled a random piece of fondant to place under the brim to give it a natural curve.
Step 13: Decorating & detail time!!!
This part was my favourite part of making the cake. It was so fun to add on all the details and slowly watch as it became more like a hat.
Here are the fondant decorating tools I used:
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEhe8sZmxhVcBrqsSAHCXZVRIccSg-XGmS1XunNDLcn3hJ44YjyVxYj0-BC2LOcMIU3XXGeqCTUx4qLOKLmCI6xyYN-BvAJcujwyPUww04-BKd5XipsBkH8T5WVegbBTzxsrdNKxwd5k6BQ/s640/FullSizeRender+%252812%2529.jpg) |
The stitching tool (mini pizza cutter looking thing) was so clutch for making this hat cake. |
I started by rolling and flattening out a bit of fondant for the top nub of the hat. Then I used the stitching tool to create the stitch lines on the brim of the hat.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEiLpSQABLHW92-WJR8r8KehNgTev7XJwjYHP_j4OteZtA6qn19wfRDeqYklSd8Tni9cbfCVpZcUkxVw-1UDE2cW9FfkHmDWBUt40JoF4YTATNZYCYcmoTPoNObZV4Q-hzTFDCsyOCacg_Q/s640/FullSizeRender+%25289%2529.jpg)
I used one of my Blue Jays hats as reference for doing the segmented lines. The hat is actually divided by 6 lines that all connect to the top nub. I used the side of a fork to lightly imprint the lines on the fondant. Then, I went over the lines with the end of the stitching tool with the bigger wheel. On either side of those lines, I noticed there were finer stitched lines. So, I used the other end of the stitching tool (the one with the smaller wheel) to create those lines. Lastly, I used the sharp pokey tool to poke 6 vent holes around the hat, in the centre of the lines. To make the vent holes stand out more, I cut out tiny circles from the black fondant to place on top of the holes that I had poked.
Last, but not least ... I cut out the "WE THE NORTH" letters from the white fondant that I had rolled out. Initially, I had printed out the words onto a piece of paper to use as a template for the letters. However, the knife I was using wasn't sharp enough, so I was having a really hard time cutting through the paper and the fondant. So, I ended up free-handing the letters.
To attach the decorative fondant pieces to the cake, I added a small amount of water to the pieces with a mini paintbrush.
To finish it all off, I used a tube of black glitter sugar gel to write my birthday message onto the cake board :) HAPPY BIRTHDAY SAMEER!!!